wage gap
Who Gets the Callback? Generative AI and Gender Bias
Chaturvedi, Sugat, Chaturvedi, Rochana
Generative artificial intelligence (AI), particularly large language models (LLMs), is being rapidly deployed in recruitment and for candidate shortlisting. We audit several mid-sized open-source LLMs for gender bias using a dataset of 332,044 real-world online job postings. For each posting, we prompt the model to recommend whether an equally qualified male or female candidate should receive an interview callback. We find that most models tend to favor men, especially for higher-wage roles. Mapping job descriptions to the Standard Occupational Classification system, we find lower callback rates for women in male-dominated occupations and higher rates in female-associated ones, indicating occupational segregation. A comprehensive analysis of linguistic features in job ads reveals strong alignment of model recommendations with traditional gender stereotypes. To examine the role of recruiter identity, we steer model behavior by infusing Big Five personality traits and simulating the perspectives of historical figures. We find that less agreeable personas reduce stereotyping, consistent with an agreeableness bias in LLMs. Our findings highlight how AI-driven hiring may perpetuate biases in the labor market and have implications for fairness and diversity within firms.
- Asia > Russia (0.14)
- North America > United States > Illinois > Cook County > Chicago (0.04)
- Europe > France (0.04)
- (3 more...)
Estimating Wage Disparities Using Foundation Models
Vafa, Keyon, Athey, Susan, Blei, David M.
One thread of empirical work in social science focuses on decomposing group differences in outcomes into unexplained components and components explained by observable factors. In this paper, we study gender wage decompositions, which require estimating the portion of the gender wage gap explained by career histories of workers. Classical methods for decomposing the wage gap employ simple predictive models of wages which condition on a small set of simple summaries of labor history. The problem is that these predictive models cannot take advantage of the full complexity of a worker's history, and the resulting decompositions thus suffer from omitted variable bias (OVB), where covariates that are correlated with both gender and wages are not included in the model. Here we explore an alternative methodology for wage gap decomposition that employs powerful foundation models, such as large language models, as the predictive engine. Foundation models excel at making accurate predictions from complex, high-dimensional inputs. We use a custom-built foundation model, designed to predict wages from full labor histories, to decompose the gender wage gap. We prove that the way such models are usually trained might still lead to OVB, but develop fine-tuning algorithms that empirically mitigate this issue. Our model captures a richer representation of career history than simple models and predicts wages more accurately. In detail, we first provide a novel set of conditions under which an estimator of the wage gap based on a fine-tuned foundation model is $\sqrt{n}$-consistent. Building on the theory, we then propose methods for fine-tuning foundation models that minimize OVB. Using data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics, we find that history explains more of the gender wage gap than standard econometric models can measure, and we identify elements of history that are important for reducing OVB.
- North America > United States > Michigan > Washtenaw County > Ann Arbor (0.14)
- North America > Mexico > Oaxaca (0.04)
- North America > United States > Wisconsin (0.04)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Cambridgeshire > Cambridge (0.04)
- Education (0.67)
- Health & Medicine (0.46)
- Information Technology > Modeling & Simulation (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (0.88)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Statistical Learning > Regression (0.46)
The Resume Paradox: Greater Language Differences, Smaller Pay Gaps
Minot, Joshua R., Maier, Marc, Demarest, Bradford, Cheney, Nicholas, Danforth, Christopher M., Dodds, Peter Sheridan, Frank, Morgan R.
Over the past decade, the gender pay gap has remained steady with women earning 84 cents for every dollar earned by men on average. Many studies explain this gap through demand-side bias in the labor market represented through employers' job postings. However, few studies analyze potential bias from the worker supply-side. Here, we analyze the language in millions of US workers' resumes to investigate how differences in workers' self-representation by gender compare to differences in earnings. Across US occupations, language differences between male and female resumes correspond to 11% of the variation in gender pay gap. This suggests that females' resumes that are semantically similar to males' resumes may have greater wage parity. However, surprisingly, occupations with greater language differences between male and female resumes have lower gender pay gaps. A doubling of the language difference between female and male resumes results in an annual wage increase of $2,797 for the average female worker. This result holds with controls for gender-biases of resume text and we find that per-word bias poorly describes the variance in wage gap. The results demonstrate that textual data and self-representation are valuable factors for improving worker representations and understanding employment inequities.
- North America > United States > Vermont > Chittenden County > Burlington (0.14)
- North America > United States > Minnesota > Hennepin County > Minneapolis (0.14)
- North America > United States > Pennsylvania > Allegheny County > Pittsburgh (0.04)
- (6 more...)
- Banking & Finance > Economy (1.00)
- Government > Regional Government > North America Government > United States Government (0.94)
Closing the Gender Wage Gap: Adversarial Fairness in Job Recommendation
Rus, Clara, Luppes, Jeffrey, Oosterhuis, Harrie, Schoenmacker, Gido H.
The goal of this work is to help mitigate the already existing gender wage gap by supplying unbiased job recommendations based on resumes from job seekers. We employ a generative adversarial network to remove gender bias from word2vec representations of 12M job vacancy texts and 900k resumes. Our results show that representations created from recruitment texts contain algorithmic bias and that this bias results in real-world consequences for recommendation systems. Without controlling for bias, women are recommended jobs with significantly lower salary in our data. With adversarially fair representations, this wage gap disappears, meaning that our debiased job recommendations reduce wage discrimination. We conclude that adversarial debiasing of word representations can increase real-world fairness of systems and thus may be part of the solution for creating fairness-aware recommendation systems.
- North America > United States > Minnesota > Hennepin County > Minneapolis (0.14)
- North America > Puerto Rico > San Juan > San Juan (0.04)
- Europe > Spain (0.04)
- (4 more...)
- Information Technology (0.68)
- Law > Civil Rights & Constitutional Law (0.46)
Closing the U.S. gender wage gap requires understanding its heterogeneity
Bach, Philipp, Chernozhukov, Victor, Spindler, Martin
In 2016, the majority of full-time employed women in the U.S. earned significantly less than comparable men. The extent to which women were affected by gender inequality in earnings, however, depended greatly on socio-economic characteristics, such as marital status or educational attainment. In this paper, we analyzed data from the 2016 American Community Survey using a high-dimensional wage regression and applying double lasso to quantify heterogeneity in the gender wage gap. We found that the gap varied substantially across women and was driven primarily by marital status, having children at home, race, occupation, industry, and educational attainment. We recommend that policy makers use these insights to design policies that will reduce discrimination and unequal pay more effectively.
- North America > United States > Minnesota > Hennepin County > Minneapolis (0.14)
- North America > Mexico > Oaxaca (0.05)
- Europe > Germany > Hamburg (0.04)
- (4 more...)
- Education > Educational Setting (0.50)
- Law > Civil Rights & Constitutional Law (0.48)
- Government > Regional Government (0.46)
Destination Hyderabad for Adobe, to set up Artificial Intelligence centre in city
Software giant Adobe will soon start operations in Hyderabad by setting up an Artificial Intelligence Center in Hyderabad. Adobe CEO Shantanu Narayen informed Minister KT Rama Rao about the decision on the sidelines of the World Congress on Information Technology, which began on Monday in the city. According to Shantanu, the availability of skilled manpower makes Hyderabad an attractive destination for IT companies. "Adobe is thrilled to announce we are starting an advanced AI lab in Hyderabad. As the global leader providing content creation and enterprise experience software solutions, driving innovative products is the core essence of our company. The abundance of tech talent in Hyderabad, coupled with the pro-business stance of Minister KT Rama Rao, makes this an exciting initiative for the growth for Adobe," he said in a press statement released by the state IT minister's office.
- North America > United States (0.07)
- Asia > India > Karnataka > Bengaluru (0.07)